Login
Belgique (Wallonie)

Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own

Cover Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own
Digital
Capitol 1119916929
Digital
Capitol -
Cover Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own
Digital
Capitol 1123618253
Cover Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own
Digital
Capitol 1124343480
Cover Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own
Digital
Capitol 1130976539
Cover Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own
Digital
Capitol 1146863870
Cover Calum Scott - Dancing On My Own
Digital
Capitol 1212552794
Digital
Capitol 1212535411

Chanson

Année:2016
Label:CAPITOL
Distributeur:UNIVERSAL
Musique/Texte:Patrik Berger
Robyn
Producteur:John McIntyre
Reprise de:Robyn - Dancing On My Own
Extrait:
Download / Stream:
Hit-parade personnel:Ajouter au hit-parade personnel

Charts

Entrée:19/11/2016 (Position 44)
Dernière semaine:28/01/2017 (Position 43)
Top:30 (1 semaine)
Chartrun:
Semaines:10
Place dans le classement général:4906 (140 points)
Airplay:29/10/2016 / Top: 23 / sem.: 12
Ultratip Bubbling Under:24/09/2016 / Top: 1 / sem.: 8
Dans d'autres pays:
ch  Top: 81 / sem.: 6
de  Top: 61 / sem.: 11
at  Top: 32 / sem.: 10
fr  Top: 58 / sem.: 13
nl  Top: 14 / sem.: 25
be  Top: 19 / sem.: 12 (V)
  Top: 30 / sem.: 10 (W)
se  Top: 4 / sem.: 30
dk  Top: 8 / sem.: 15
au  Top: 2 / sem.: 23
nz  Top: 5 / sem.: 22

Tracks

03/06/2016
Digital Capitol - (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own
  4:22
2.Dancing On My Own (Tiësto Remix)
  3:46
   
03/06/2016
Digital Capitol 1119916929 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own
  4:20
   
24/06/2016
Digital Capitol 1123618253 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own (Acoustic)
4:13
   
24/06/2016
Digital Capitol 1124343480 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own (Instrumental)
4:17
   
08/07/2016
Digital Capitol 1130976539 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own (Tiësto Remix)
3:44
   
02/09/2016
Digital Capitol 1146863870 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own (Ben Dooks Remix)
5:43
   
17/03/2017
Digital Capitol 1212552794 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own (Toby Green Remix)
3:31
   
17/03/2017
Digital Capitol 1212535411 (UMG)
Montrer détailsÉcouter tout
1.Dancing On My Own (Toby Green Remix)
3:31
   

Disponible sur

VersionDuréeTitreLabel
Numéro
Format
Medium
Date
4:20Dancing On My OwnCapitol
1119916929
Single
Digital
03/06/2016
4:22Dancing On My OwnCapitol
-
Single
Digital
03/06/2016
Tiësto Remix3:46Dancing On My OwnCapitol
-
Single
Digital
03/06/2016
Acoustic4:13Dancing On My OwnCapitol
1123618253
Single
Digital
24/06/2016
Instrumental4:17Dancing On My OwnCapitol
1124343480
Single
Digital
24/06/2016
»» tout montrer

Calum Scott   Discographie / Devenir fan

Singles - Ultratop
TitreEntréeTopsem.
Dancing On My Own19/11/20163010
You Are The Reason (Duet Version) (Calum Scott & Leona Lewis)24/03/20181115
 
Albums - Ultratop
TitreEntréeTopsem.
Only Human17/03/20189010
 

Reviews

Moyenne des notes: 3.12 (Reviews: 50)

ahmetyal
Member
****
great but not better than the original

Kamala
Member
***
...die Stimme hier .... ich breche mein Schweigen .... ich mag dieses Cover, so schrill gesungen, nicht...

da_hooliii
Member
**
Es ist zwar auch mal schön einen gefühlvollen Song zu machen aber hier ist mir zu viel Gejaule dabei und da wird für mich die Musik etwas unglaubwürdig.

RentnerHD
Member
***
Okay..

lumlucky
Member
***
nicht schlecht, nicht recht...

Redhawk1
Member
***
Ruhige Pianomusik, die 1er verstehe ich nicht? ..So schlecht ist's auch wieder nicht ;)

Widmann1
Member
***
Der ist mir zu ruhig, zu reduziert.

Zacco333
Member
*
When I first noticed the existence of this, I assumed it was a trop house cover. Now I wish it was because not even the worst trop house dreck is as bad as this piece of shit. When will people get that acoustic/stripped back covers (or acoustic/stripped back songs in general) does not = automatically good!!! This is exhibit A of how not to cover a song, it does no justice to the original. His voice is terrible and I echo what has already been said about this by others. Tiësto's version is a waste of time also, only barely more tolerable.

sanremo
Member
**
2+

Uebi
Member
*****
Hm, da ich das Original überhaupt nicht kenne, kann ich vorurteilsfrei an den Song herangehen. Schöne Pianoballade, genau wie ich sie mag, eindrücklich vorgetragen. Gute 5.

rotrigodelafuente
Member
****
nettes cover-liedchen, nett vorgetragen. kommt jedoch natürlich niemals an das original von der grossartigen und wunderbaren robyn heran ;-)

Alphabet
Member
*
Schrecklich. Kein Vergleich zur fulminanten Version von Robyn.

Das ist ist seelenloses Nachsingen mit Betroffenheitsklavier im Hintergrund und nöliger Stimme am Mikro.

!Xabbu
Member
****
gefällt sogar ein wenig.
gefühl ist in der stimme definitiv vorhanden.

Rewer
hitparade.ch
***
...weniger...

southpaw
Member
****
Das angebetete Individuum küsst SIE? Ja dann hat der gute Calum natürlich keine Chance :-)

Klar hinter dem Original, aber eine 4 minus liegt drin.

Werner
Member
***
...lahm und mit zu weinerlicher Stimme...

fabio
Member
****
3-4

JimJim1
Member
**
It's pretty bland compared to the original.

ul.tra
Member
****
Finde ich überraschend gut. In uk war das ein Platz 2

tgebele
Member
*
Ein Cover und dazu noch völlig schwach gesungen. Da kann es nur eine Wertung geben....

Chemmical
Member
*
Everything has been said about this disgraceful cover so I won't repeat anybody. The most infuriating aspect of it is that, with this song becoming a big hit, there seems to be a high demand for this stripped back approach so I'm sure we can expect more in the future.

Mykl_77
Member
*
Absolutely terrible cover. The song tries to show the emotion, but if anything there's nothing. His voice grates on me too, one of the worst for the year.

Linsanity1996
Member
*
Awfully bland and cliche rubbish. I hate this with a passion and his voice sucks because he sounds constipated the whole time.

Hijinx
Member
*
Ideally this should serve as a wake up call, but it won't. Trends don't truly go away until they overexpose themselves to the point that everyone recognises them, but this is one that not only crops up just on occasion, but one that inherently relies on the very same obfuscation to keep it going.

It's just a shame that it's rooted in such systemic bigotry because this is something that we should not have to see ever. I'm sure you know the drill, Britain's Got Talent finalist covers a song by Robyn, removes the pop and dance elements and turns it into a SERIOUS BALLAD. Public laps it up because it fills in that SERIOUS BALLAD market who are disillusioned by a market of Chainsmokers & Calvin Harris.

The underlying problem is that ironically, it's devoid of substance, or at the very least, goes some ways to remove some of it from the original recording. When Robyn sings "Dancing On My Own", she draws strength from the context of the record. It's a euphoric dance, she's not in the mood, because she can see her ex with another woman, well and truly moved on from her. Dancing is her tension release. It's one of the saddest pop songs of the decade.

This version relies on artiface and expectations based on associations. Because the general public will have a built in perception that pop music, particularly modern pop music and especially dance music is frivolous and disposable. We're built up to believe that music performed on organic instrumentation, is inherently music of class & substance. There's also another underlying problem that either through social expectations or hubris, women are far more likely to give out kudos to music performed by men than vice versa, something not helped by decades upon decades of canonisation.

The bottom line is that every time this happens, where a pop song is stripped back for a cover, there will be armies of people who insist that the cover is objectively better or more emotional than the original, even though it's literally the same song, with literally less substance because there's more removed than there is added.

There has been no shortage of offensive covers in the charts of late, but this is the most offensive because of what it stands for. No one's hailing Jonas Blue's version of "Fast Car" as a masterpiece, it's just that frivolous, disposable fun, while the original is already too canonised to be shaken by this. But this version threatens to overwrite the original. This is the version of "Dancing On My Own" that will get played on radio for decades to come. You'll never be able to discuss the original version of the song without having to call back to this. I'm going to download Robyn's version and never listen to this again.
Dernière édition: 24/11/2016 09:06

jayj95
Member
***
I'm sort of into it but I don't want to hear it every 5 minutes... would of liked it to go to #1 (it was better than Closer).
Dernière édition: 22/12/2016 01:28

silvm
Member
*
s.h.i.t!

Kirin
Member
****
Durchaus gelungene Version.

RV
Member
*****
Ik ben niet al te bekend met het origineel van Robyn, maar ik hoor best dat deze jongen kan zingen. Gevoelige en sfeervolle cover die mij persoonlijk wel kan bekoren.

brosa0
Member
******
The original Calum Scott version is meh and adds nothing to the song.

The Tiesto remix is amazing and gives it the edge that it needs.

TravD
Member
***
Original: 3.4*
Remix: 3.4*

Chartsfohlen
Member
***
Sehr schwerfällige Version des wirklich wunderbaren Robyn-Songs. Gibt mir nichts und wäre von mir sofort wieder vergessen worden, hätte ich die Nummer erstmals so gehört. Meines Erachtens unnötig.

Chartsguru
Member
****
Der Tiesto Remix ist gelungen. Daher eine 4 von mir.

Blairben
Member
*
This ain't got nothing on the original.

Besnik
Member
****
Klingt zwar ziemlich ok umgesetzt, aber kommt niemals an mein heissgeliebtes Original ran! Von Robyn eine 6, hier eine 4!

NationOfZealots
Member
*
See sirvmr's review. Not a fan of ruminating chamber pop covers.

WTF this is only charting so high in comparison to the original due to overhype and payola.
Dernière édition: 23/09/2016 14:50

josh4u92
Member
******
Such a great song, sung with great feeling and emotion. Never heard the original until I heard this version and I have to say I prefer this version over Robyn's.
Dernière édition: 15/09/2016 18:34

alleyt1989
Member
*
I think everyone listening to the Robyn original knew that it was a sad song hidden behind a good dance beat and that's one of the reasons I loved that song when it came out. This is much more basic and showcases the lyrics more, but we've heard it all before so I don't think it was necessary. Also the voice is not so good.

Nah this sucks.
Dernière édition: 21/11/2016 07:32

irelander
Member
**
Pointlessly overpowering the vocals ≠ more interesting song. In fact it gives greater rise to the fact that the rest of the track makes such little impact that it's basically a glorified The Voice performance without the squealing crowd. Certainly not awful but not worth one's time. 2.25

bluezombie
Member
***
This is probably more my style of music than the original, but his voice, well it's not that it's necessarily bad, he just seems to be straining way too hard and it's sounding forced. Or maybe his voice is kinda bad.

LIFTER500
Member
***
Quite weak. 2.8.

DeejayDave
Member
*****
Vergeleken met het magische origineel komt dit toch een beetje rauw op m'n dak. Die jongen kan best zingen maar van dit nummer blijf je gewoon af.

Edit: Vooruit, een verhoging. Dit nummer blijft onverwoestbaar mooi, ook in de versie van Scott. Jammer van die Tiësto remix.
Dernière édition: 29/10/2016 15:06

Fabio (auch Fabi GaGa)
Member
*****
Eine wunderschön gesungene Piano Interpretation dieser Nummer! Calum hat eine wundervoll, warme Stimme die mir zusagt. Auch der Tiesto Remix vermag zu überzeugen!
5*

Jeroen68
Member
****
Mooie balladversie van een vrij middelmatig en hysterisch dansnummer.

gherkin
Member
***
Geen rotslechte versie, maar ik krijg de indruk dat een tragere versie van de hit van Robyn nu niet meer zo origineel is.

sirvmr
Member
***
The guy's got an okay version, but I'm always a bit miffed when a subpar cover outpeaks an outstanding original. Both this and Jonas Blue's "Fast Car" have done that this year. Enough for me.

TaylorHarris
Member
******
Ich kenne das Original nicht. Den Song hörte ich bloss, weil ich sah, dass er seit einiger Zeit stetig steigt in den britischen iTunes-Charts. "Schöner Track", dachte ich, "4* könnte ich geben".

Dann sah ich plötzlich was von "Audition Britain's Got Talent" und da ich ziemlich begeistert von solchen Auditions bin, dachte ich, ich höre es mir mal an.

Als Calum anfing zu singen, war ich plötzlich weg, in einer ganz anderen Welt, ich musste ihm zuhören, konnte nicht wegschauen, obwohl der Song noch ziemlich lahm war aber plötzlich schlug sie ein, diese tolle, neue Stimme. Die Gänsehaut war am ganzen Körper und tränen flossen sofort. Sowas habe ich noch nie erlebt!

Wie könnte ich nun also anders, als diesem Herrn mit diesem grossen Song nicht die Höchstnote zu vergeben?

Übrigens, Live definitiv noch bombastischer als in der Studio-Version.


sophieellisbextor
Staff
*****
L'une des reprises les plus sincères et touchantes que l'on ait pu entendre dans un télécrochet. Ravi du succès outre-Manche.

Der_Nagel
Member
***
Ich ziehe doch deutlich das Original von Robyn dieser Pianopop-Version vor…

der Herr nahm bei der neunten Staffel von Britain's Got Talent (2015) teil und belegte im Finale den sechsten Platz – 2.75…

Miraculi
Member
****
Das Original von Robyn ist ein Klassiker aus der Neuzeit - hier eine gute Fassung von einem Teilnehmer des "Britain's Got Talent" Contests. Das Klavier begleitet eine frische neue Stimme mit viel Melancholie.
Ajouter une review
Belgique (Flandre) Allemagne Australie Autriche Danemark Espagne Finlande France Italie Norvège Nouvelle-Zélande Pays-Bas Portugal Suède Suisse
nederlandsenglish
LOGIN
MOT DE PASSE
Mot de passe oublié?
Notre site web utilise des cookies pour offrir à ses lecteurs la meilleure expérience du site web. Dans certains cas, les cookies sont également mis en place par des services tiers. Vous trouverez de plus amples informations dans notre déclaration de protection des données.